10:31 p.m.
While setting up this DHCP/DNS server, I got reminded of Caddy
I’m busy replacing nginx with Caddy, for the simple reasons:
- simpl(er) configs
- API
- Automatic LE HTTPS certificate fetching
Also consider this as a possiblity/etc. especially when not needing all the WAF from
nginx
10:32 p.m.
Forgot to mention the url: https://caddyserver.com/docs/download
On 24 Jul 2020, at 22:31 , hvjunk <hvjunk(a)gmail.com> wrote:
While setting up this DHCP/DNS server, I got reminded of Caddy
I’m busy replacing nginx with Caddy, for the simple reasons:
- simpl(er) configs
- API
- Automatic LE HTTPS certificate fetching
Also consider this as a possiblity/etc. especially when not needing all the WAF from
nginx
12:14 a.m.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512
On 2020-07-24 22:32, hvjunk wrote:
Forgot to mention the url: https://caddyserver.com/docs/download
> On 24 Jul 2020, at 22:31 , hvjunk <hvjunk(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
> While setting up this DHCP/DNS server, I got reminded of Caddy
>
> I’m busy replacing nginx with Caddy, for the simple reasons: - simpl(er)
> configs - API - Automatic LE HTTPS certificate fetching
>
> Also consider this as a possiblity/etc. especially when not needing all
> the WAF from nginx
Nginx is heavily integrated in DebOps, because so many solutions have a web
interface and Nginx is used for common things like HTTPS, logging,
authentication, client certificates and so on. Also, some roles have complex
location configurations.
Caddy is currently not in Debian. Ref:
https://github.com/debops/debops/wiki/DebOps-roles-in-development
Can you confirm that everything Nginx is currently used for can be done by
Caddy as well? Do you really think it is worth the effort for DebOps? And last
question, would you be willing to do the major work of this?
- --
Live long and prosper
Robin `ypid` Schneider -- https://me.ypid.de/
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----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=bBn2
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
12:36 a.m.
On 25 Jul 2020, at 00:14 , Robin Schneider <ypid(a)riseup.net>
wrote:
Nginx is heavily integrated in DebOps, because so many solutions have a web
interface and Nginx is used for common things like HTTPS, logging,
authentication, client certificates and so on. Also, some roles have complex
location configurations.
Yes, configurations that is also doable in Caddy, and you don’t need an extra CertBot for
it’s certificates.
Caddy is currently not in Debian. Ref:
https://github.com/debops/debops/wiki/DebOps-roles-in-development
Just as PostgreSQL 12 and other that’s not in Debian, it’s a matter of adding a source
repository
Can you confirm that everything Nginx is currently used for can be
done by
Caddy as well? Do you really think it is worth the effort for DebOps? And last
question, would you be willing to do the major work of this?
Caddy is another tool. A tool in my opinion that is solving more problems in the
current httpS only world, and where just about every web interface is a socket away and
packaged by
a server like haproxy/lighttpd/apache2/nginx/caddy to be put behind a HTTPS SNI+path.
I’m not saying thrown out nginx, but I’ll be moving (especially my Mendix deploys) and
other front ends to caddy, at which point I’ll
give back my changes/amendments.
Do notice that I mentioned initially the WAF features of Nginx, as that is a reason not to
use Caddy.
haproxy has other HA features that Caddy also doesn’t have.
But for the most cases, you might just find Caddy simpler than Nginx, especially when you
don’t have to do CertBots.
1365
days inactive
1365
days old
3 comments
2 participants
participants (2)
-
hvjunk -
Robin Schneider